We all know that tastes in gardens differs widely from person to person and place to place but on a trip to southern India last year I realise how drastic that difference can be. One place where that was very evident, as you’ll see from some of the images in this post, was in a large public garden known as the Rajah’s Seat in Madikeri, capital of the former princely state of Coorg. It was an eye-opening experience in every sense.
The whole place was a shock to a westerner used to classical statues and subtle planting because there are enormous figures of rhinos, snakes and even artillery in the middle of colourful planting so bright that it ought to come with a health warning about possible damage to one’s eyes!
There are alsø spectacular but vertigo-inducing views down into the valley below from a small open but railed-in pavilion, and several other viewing platforms and gazebos.
I was very intrigued by the whole place, but none of the staff or anyone else we spoke to knew its history so obviously I decided to investigate further when I got home via the byways of the internet and the India Office records at the British Library.

As usual the photos are my own unless otherwise acknowledged
The story goes that the Rajas of Coorg [now Kodagu] and their families would come down here in the evening from their palace, about a kilometre’s walk away to the north, to enjoy the landscape and sunset. The present local and tourist authorities repeat that idea, although rather cautiously describing it as “popular lore”. We were told that the seat or mantapa dates from these early princely times. It’s certainly a protected monument and listed by the Archaeological Survey of India although no date is given.
The main part garden is on level ground between the pavilion and the road, with another section leading along steep terraced paths to the south east to another viewing point. The seat itself sits on the edge of what is almost a sheer drop into the wooded valley below. As you can see the main section is in typical quadripartite form and led me to think that the like so many other public spaces in India it had been designed by the British during colonial days and then “Indianized” post-independence.

But before I try to unravel the story of the gardens let’s have a look at what they are like today.

Colourful is the first word that springs to mind!

The western idea of flower beds and borders don’t really work here. Instead there are areas where plants are mounded up…

or perhaps set out in lots of serried ranks of pots…
…or mass planted with what most westerners would probably think of as having little regard for harmonious colour blending and no sense of delicate pastel shades a la Gertrude Jekyll

Even the fencing and pathways are colourful
Like other ex-colonial gardens that I’ve written about before such as the Botanical Gardens at Ooty or the National Botanic Gardens of Burma, which were both colonial creations that have been adapted to modern local styles and taste, there is also a sense of theme park fun.

The pavilion with large animal figures dotted around it in the the grounds…

and because of the status of the army locally there are floral tributes to them too

My visit coincided with a flower festival and whether one likes it or not it’s hard not to be impressed by the sheer scale of this rendering of a local historic temple, like the cannon above, covered in cut flowers – mainly chrysanthemums which seem very popular here.


Away from the gaudy main area of the garden the paths leading out and down the valley side are probably more “Mediterranean” in feel – although Coorg is known as the Scotland of South India because of its mountains and rainfall
However the planting is to my western eye unusual, with rows of what are houseplants at home running vertically down the steep slopes.

The paths lead to other seating areas 
… shelters and viewpoints

There is a small entry fee and gardens are well looked after by a small army of gardeners – mainly men as far as I could see – and another of weeders – all women, some of whom are seen here having a rest in the shade but as a result there is no litter and weeds don’t stand a chance.
But enough of these colourful extravaganzas what about the garden’s history? That proved slightly harder to track than I expected.
Madikeri became the principal royal centre of the state in the 17th century and so it’s sometimes said that the pavilion was built then but when I started looking I could find no evidence of that. The last Rajah of Coorg was deposed by the British in 1834 and his kingdom absorbed into the growing colonial empire. At least that meant there ought to be good documentary evidence because British India was highly organised and bureaucratic, publishing regular accounts of almost every aspect of government including detailing of public works and archaeology. Later in the 19th century the hills of Coorg proved very suitable for coffee growing and so European planters began to settle while tourists and missionaries came in increasing numbers and wrote about their visits.
To my surprise, however, there’s very little mention of the Rajah’s Seat and none at all about the gardens or of the pavilion in any of these accounts or reports. The first mention of the Seat itself isn’t until 1876 when Lewis Rice drew up Mysore and Coorg: A Gazetteer compiled for the Government of India [1876] which also included the history of the Coorg rulers. He reports that one of the recent rulers ,Linga Raja, was excessively cruel and threw some of his enemies off ” a precipice on the hill side, near the Raja’s Seat” So the idyllic royal sunset viewpoint also carried less pleasant connotations.
So what happened to the Rajah’s Seat and the area around its immediately after the annexation of Coorg and in the 40 years up until Rice’s comments? Captain Richard Barron was an early military officer on the scene and painted this view of Mercara as Madikeri was then known. It was then not much more a village around thePalace/Fort which can be seen in the middle distance, but there’s no sign of the Rajah’s Seat.
Equally annoying is an account of Mercara in the Illustrated London News in 1866 which again cuts off the area where the Rajah’s Seat stands.
Luckily there is a map of the town drawn up in 1854 and it contained my first real surprise. Although the map stops short of the precipice itself and so doesn’t include the site of the pavilion as the detail on the right shows it does includes the area of the modern garden which is marked “Burial Ground”.
European life expectancy in India at the time was often quite short so a cemetery was an obvious early requirement. Level ground within a beautiful setting clearly made the area around Rajah’s Seat a suitable site.
That sent me looking in a completely different direction: the archives of the British Association for Cemeteries in South Asia (or BACSA for short). There I discovered that there were 106 identifiable gravestones, ranging from Lieutenant Joseph Arthur who was buried in January 1838, to Alice Hillman, whose burial in 1934 was the last known.
The reason BACSA took an interest is because in 1966 the European burial ground had been cleared, and the gravestones dumped in a neighbouring field while the site was turned into a garden. There had been protests led by General Cariappa, a local Indian army officer and as a result the tombstones were relocated to a new cemetery and a plaque erected to explain what had happened. In other words the garden was not, as might be been supposed from its layout, a colonial creation but one driven by the need for the growing town to have some decent open green space.
It only left three questions to answer: was the pavilion part of an earlier royal garden that was converted into a cemetery and if not when was it built? Despite all the local claims about the long royal connections to the site I can find absolutely no evidence to substantiate that claim. Nor, again contradicting local belief, does the pavilion appear to be very old . When the Archaeological Survey of India published its List of Architectural and Archaeological Remains in Coorg in 1894 there is no mention of the seat, which one would have expected had it dated from the time of the Rajas. That makes me wonder whether early references to “Raja’s Seat” actually meant a literal physical building or perhaps more likely, as with Arthur’s Seat in Edinburgh simply a place with a great prospect.

Certainly the architecture of the pavilion itself is so basic it could be of almost any date but in fact it isn’t mentioned anywhere until 1916 when the Archaeological Department’s annual report records expenditure on the “Fort and Raja’s seat” and describes the actual work as repairs to the road leading to the Raja’s Seat, repairs and whitewashing of its parapet wall. Whether that’s the parapet of the pavilion or the retaining wall between it and the precipice isn’t clear. There are later references to minor repairs and repainting right through the 1950s and 70s but I found no answer ton the third question: why is it surrounded by railings with no public access.
Eventually I contacted the Karnataka State Tourist Board who came up with another and probably more credible possibility. They say the pavilion known as Gandhi Mantapa was built in order to commemorate the visit of Mahatma Gandhi to Coorg in 1934 where he addressed the local people. It is regarded as a sacred place, hence the railings and is the centrepiece for a commemoration held there every year on January 30th – the day of his assassination. There is a procession following an urn containing some of his ashes through the town to the gardens and pavilion for prayers and a time of silence his memory. So I suspect the truth is that while there may have been a structure there during the days of the Rajas it was not substantial and had disappeared by the time the cemetery was established, while the current pavilion probably does date from some point after 1934 and before the 1950s.
I’ve been holding this post back for a long time in the hope that I’d be able to say something more authoritative but without any luck. It just shows how quickly people/systems forget and how easy it is for history to “disappear” . I wonder how many of the countless visitors, Indian or tourists, have much of a clue of the whole story?
This time I’m afraid there isn’t anywhere I can recommend for further information, but there are thousands of photos of the gardens on-line if you want to shock your eyes some more!









You must be logged in to post a comment.